RTÉ Radio 1|5234 - "There are far too many civil servants doing nothing"
Kieran Cuddihy takes your calls and gets to the heart of the discussions that matter to the people of Ireland.
00:00
00:00
Episode's summary
This episode of Live Line features a debate over ongoing strikes by nurses and teachers. Callers discuss the impact of inflation on wages and poor working conditions for nurses, while others express skepticism regarding teacher pay and criticize the motivations of civil service unions.
The discussion further explores the complexities of public sector pay negotiations, contrasting teacher salaries with nursing workloads. Speakers critique trade unions for seeking pay parity during economic booms and call for greater government accountability and productivity within the civil service.
Chapters
Click on a chapter to go directly to that moment
Highlights
If I treated one of my employees the way my daughter is treated by her employer, who's the even the government, I'd be put in jail.
00:01:27 · A caller compares the treatment of nurses to illegal employment practices to highlight the severity of their working conditions.
They're understaffed. They're overworked. Like, there's days that she goes in there. There was one day she had 18 patients to herself.
00:02:51 · The caller provides specific examples of the dangerous workload nurses face due to understaffing.
That money should be redirected into the wages, especially with groups like nurses that need it.
00:07:26 · A caller argues that budget increases for infrastructure projects like the Dublin Metro should instead be used to fund essential worker wages.
The greed amongst the civil service trade unions is absolutely appalling.
00:13:19 · A caller criticizes the motivations of civil service unions during pay negotiations.
Residing over decisions like the Department of the Arts Council. Six million euros spent on a system that didn't work. Who got fired for that? Nobody.
00:16:45 · The speaker uses an example of failed government spending to highlight the lack of accountability in the public sector.
This episode of Live Line features a debate over ongoing strikes by nurses and teachers. Callers discuss the impact of inflation on wages and poor working conditions for nurses, while others express skepticism regarding teacher pay and criticize the motivations of civil service unions.
The discussion further explores the complexities of public sector pay negotiations, contrasting teacher salaries with nursing workloads. Speakers critique trade unions for seeking pay parity during economic booms and call for greater government accountability and productivity within the civil service.
Published14 Oct 2026
Duration17:07
Episodes
5234-
"There are far too many civil servants doing nothing"
Listened
This episode of Live Line features a debate over ongoing strikes by nurses and teachers. Callers discuss the impact of inflation on wages and poor working conditions for nurses, while others express skepticism regarding teacher pay and criticize the motivations of civil service unions.
The discussion further explores the complexities of public sector pay negotiations, contrasting teacher salaries with nursing workloads. Speakers critique trade unions for seeking pay parity during economic booms and call for greater government accountability and productivity within the civil service.
14 Oct 2026
5233-
"I was asked to participate in a murder"
Listened
Ciarán Cudahy and criminologist Robert Cullen discuss the cycle of drug-related debt, intimidation, and violence, exploring the 'credible messenger' model as a way to mediate community conflicts. The conversation examines the social implications of current drug laws, the complexities of addiction, and the biological drives behind substance use.
The episode features a heated debate regarding drug policy, crime prevention, and the effectiveness of the prison system. While Robert argues that prohibition fuels violence and that prison is criminogenic, Chris advocates for more robust policing and harsher penalties to deter criminal activity.
14 Oct 2026
5232-
"Dealer after dealer calling up looking for money"
Listened
A harrowing personal account of a mother's experience with drug-related intimidation and the devastating impact of her son's cocaine addiction. The speaker describes being targeted by dealers at her home, facing escalating debt collection demands that totaled approximately £10,000, and experiencing property damage including smashed windows. The conversation explores the psychological toll of living in a constant state of fear and paranoia, the connection between recreational drug use and organized crime violence, and the urgent need for better education and targeted resources to combat drug-related intimidation.
14 Oct 2026
5231-
"It takes a special kind of person to do the work they do"
Listened
This episode features a series of heated debates regarding upcoming public sector strike action in Ireland, focusing on the demands of teachers and nurses. Callers present conflicting views, weighing the necessity of pay increases due to inflation and the cost of living against concerns over job privilege and the economic disruption caused by industrial action.
The conversation also covers critical issues in healthcare, including breast cancer screening density and personal accounts of hospital understaffing. Additionally, the discussion touches upon the impact of inflation on real wages and the emigration of essential workers driven by economic pressures.
13 Oct 2026
5230-
"I knew nothing about dense breasts"
Listened
This episode explores the urgent campaign for standardized breast density notification in Ireland. Through personal testimonies and interviews with activists, the program highlights how the failure to report dense breast tissue on mammogram results can mask tumors and increase the risk of developing cancer. The discussion focuses on a recent meeting at Leinster House where advocates met with politicians to demand that the Minister for Health mandate the inclusion of density information in all BreastCheck results.
The conversation details the medical implications of dense breast tissue, including its role in obscuring invasive lobular and ductal cancers. It also addresses the systemic delays in healthcare reviews, noting that official reports regarding this issue may not be finalized until 2027 or later, leaving many women without vital information for their long-term health decisions.
13 Oct 2026
5229-
"We are asking people to respect the picket line, be that in person or remotely"
Listened
This episode features a debate between former teacher Pat and SIPTU education organiser Cathy Shields regarding upcoming teacher strikes and the broader public sector pay dispute. The discussion explores whether strike action is an unfair way to pressure parents or a democratically mandated response to the cost of living crisis.
The conversation further examines the responsibility for industrial action, weighing the importance of prioritized negotiations against the government's failure to initiate talks before contract expirations. The debate also includes perspectives on the government's financial capacity to fund better pay deals and the potential social consequences of prolonged industrial action.
12 Oct 2026
5228-
"Where is George Gibney? He's in jail"
Listened
This episode covers the sentencing of Olympic swimming coach George Gibney to 15 and a half years in prison for serial sexual abuse. Through interviews with journalist Justine McCarthy and survivors Chalky White and Trish Carney, the episode explores the emotional impact of the verdict and the long struggle for justice.
The discussion further examines the long-term impact of Gibney's crimes, the legal battles faced by whistleblowers like Gary O'Toole, and the historical failures of the state to prosecute him. Finally, Justine McCarthy reflects on the systemic culture of silence in Ireland and the US that allowed such abuse to go unprosecuted, emphasizing the ongoing need for accountability within judicial and sporting institutions.
12 Oct 2026
5227-
"I've lost my parents and I didn't get as many flowers"
Listened
This episode covers a recent incident of extreme animal cruelty in Cork, where Tracey's Persian cat, Felix, was kidnapped by individuals on an e-bike and later found dead from severe injuries. Guests and listeners discuss the psychological implications of such violence, the difficulty of accessing CCTV footage due to privacy laws, and the urgent need for legal reforms regarding animal cruelty prosecution.
The conversation also explores the profound grief experienced by pet owners, featuring calls from listeners expressing outrage and support. Additionally, the episode touches on the availability of pet loss bereavement services through the Irish Blue Cross to assist those struggling with the death of a companion animal.
09 Oct 2026
5226-
"Hopefully we'll get four weeks in Brazil next summer"
Listened
Reporting from Kazakhstan, this episode covers the Republic of Ireland women's football team's dominant 8-0 victory over Kazakhstan. The discussion details the match performance, including possession statistics and the difficulty of the upcoming playoff draw against either Belgium or Poland. The segment also touches upon the logistics of following international football across Europe and the broader implications for World Cup qualification and a potential trip to Brazil.
09 Oct 2026
5225-
"You don't have to watch it if you don't want to"
Listened
This episode features a debate regarding the proposal by US Secretary of Defence Pete Hegseth to live-stream the execution of Nidal Hasan, the Fort Hood shooter, making it the first public execution in the United States since 1936. The discussion brings together multiple perspectives on the efficacy and morality of capital punishment.
Panelists debate whether such a spectacle serves as a deterrent to future crimes or if it merely promotes revenge and dehumanization. Arguments range from the potential for executing innocent individuals due to judicial error to the personal emotional responses of victims' families. The conversation also touches upon the psychological impact of witnessing state-sanctioned killing via digital media.
09 Oct 2026
5224-
"We got used to the milestones but they're adults now"
Listened
A heartwarming segment featuring the famous quadruplets from Ballin, County Carlow, who have all successfully passed their driving tests on their first attempt. The episode includes an interview with driving instructor Michael Canavan and one of the siblings, Lily, discussing the shared milestones of the siblings' lives, from starting school to voting. The conversation also features the siblings' mother, Mary, reflecting on the logistics of raising four children simultaneously and the family's transition as the siblings enter adulthood and various career paths.
09 Oct 2026
5223-
"No two 'silent calls' were the same..."
Listened
Nuala Ward and Joni Crone reflect on the history and impact of the Galway Lesbian and Gay Healthline, discussing the challenges of providing support during an era of intense social isolation and a lack of visible LGBTQ+ identity in Ireland. The episode explores the early days of the Lesbian Line, highlighting the difficulties of operating from makeshift locations and navigating a highly religious society.
The discussion also covers the experiences of volunteers on the Dublin Lesbian Line, including the emotional weight of handling traumatic silent calls and the sense of community found in the service. Through personal stories, the speakers recount the personal courage required to live authentically amidst public prejudice and the profound impact of finding identity through advocacy and support services.
08 Oct 2026
5222-
"It needs to happen here"
Listened
In this episode of Live Line with Ciarán Cudahy, Lorna Quirk discusses an upcoming protest at Leinster House aimed at the Minister for Health. The campaign calls for the introduction of standardized breast density notification within BreastCheck results for all women in Ireland. The discussion explores the medical implications of dense breast tissue, which can make cancer harder to detect on mammograms, and compares the current Irish system to practices in Australia and parts of the United States.
Quirk shares her personal experience with a stage three breast cancer diagnosis to highlight how access to density information could enable women to advocate for supplemental screening. The conversation also addresses the potential economic benefits of earlier detection for the HSE and families, arguing that providing this information is a vital component of modern breast health.
07 Oct 2026
5221-
"The children that have the least amount of time left are left waiting the longest"
Listened
In this episode of Live Line, a mother shares the intense daily challenges of caring for her four-year-old son, Jack, who has a rare and severe condition. She discusses the lack of accessible parking, the inadequacy of government support, and the exhausting 24/7 medical routine required to keep him safe.
Radio hosts and several carers, including Maria and Aisling, discuss the extreme hardships of caring for children with high needs. The conversation covers the impact of sleep deprivation, the financial strain of home adaptations, and a shared frustration with recent government budgets that fail to recognize the reality of caregiving.
07 Oct 2026
5220-
"I found out yesterday that he's been missing since 1992"
Listened
Gerry O'Sullivan recounts the heartbreaking news regarding the death of his brother, Patsy, who had been missing since 1992. He discusses the details of the investigation, the emotional toll of the disappearance, and the recent discovery of his brother's passing via a news article.
Nicky Aldridge describes discovering her long-lost Uncle Pat through a Facebook article, leading to a reconnection with Gerry. The episode explores the complexities of Patsy's decision to start a new life in London due to the social pressures of that era, and Gerry's plans to memorialize his brother.
07 Oct 2026
5219-
"I had to carry my son's coffin, he should be here carrying mine"
Listened
In this emotional episode of Liveline, Dermot Maguire shares the tragic story of his 14-year-old son Daniel, who died from inhaling deodorant. As Dermot faces a terminal cancer diagnosis, he discusses his family's mission to warn other parents about the dangers of aerosol and nitrous oxide inhalation.
The discussion expands to address the widespread availability of these substances in the community, with Senator Theresa Costas highlighting the alarming number of canisters being recovered. Guests explore the severe neurological and physiological risks of inhalant abuse, the role of social media in facilitating access, and the urgent need for education and open conversation between parents and children.
05 Oct 2026
5218-
Catcalling
Listened
This episode of Liveline explores the pervasive reality of street harassment and its profound impact on women's safety and freedom. Through personal accounts from individuals like Niamh, Michelle, and Tanya, the conversation details the psychological toll of frequent catcalling, being followed, and verbal intimidation, which often forces women to alter their daily routines and abandon activities like running.
The discussion delves into the normalization of such behavior, examining how men often dismiss harassment as 'just a compliment' and the critical need for male accountability. Featuring insights from Emily O'Gorman on underreporting and discussions regarding legislative efforts to address public sexual harassment, the episode emphasizes that true change requires both legal action and a fundamental cultural shift.
02 Oct 2026
5217-
Catcalling
Listened
This episode of Liveline explores the pervasive and psychological impact of street harassment and catcalling. Through personal accounts from women like Niamh and Michelle, the conversation details how frequent verbal and non-verbal harassment creates a climate of fear, forcing many to alter their daily routines and abandon activities like running for their own safety.
The discussion extends to the normalization of such behavior, examining how men often dismiss harassment as 'just a compliment' and the critical role of male accountability. The episode also covers legislative efforts to address public sexual harassment and reflects on how generational patterns and social environments contribute to the ongoing issue.
02 Oct 2026
5216-
"Something is going to give"
Listened
This episode explores the escalating student protests in Ireland, centered on the 'Fund Our Futures' movement. The discussion covers the acute student housing crisis, the financial strain of hidden education costs, and the significant funding deficits facing higher education institutions.
The conversation expands into broader socio-economic challenges, including the impact of the housing shortage on professional emigration, the need for skilled tradespeople to address infrastructure needs, and the debate over the value of liberal arts versus technical education in a changing global economy.
01 Oct 2026
5215-
"People can't afford to buy on the high street"
Listened
A debate on RTE Radio 1's Live Line regarding the implementation of a five euro import tax on online shopping from outside the EU, often referred to as the Temu tax. The discussion features callers debating the economic impact of the new handling fees and import duties on consumer habits and local Irish businesses. One caller highlights the financial strain on households facing inflation and the necessity of cheap imports for specific needs, while another argues that the influx of Chinese goods creates an unfair disadvantage for local retailers who pay VAT, PRSI, and local rates.
30 Sep 2026
5214-
"We're all at a loss"
Listened
A recent student from Mary Immaculate College in Limerick, Laura McKearnen, discusses the sudden postponement of graduation ceremonies scheduled for October 22nd and 23rd. The college has moved the ceremony to spring 2027, citing potential industrial action by public service unions. The delay has caused significant distress among graduates due to non-refundable travel and accommodation costs, as well as the long timeframe until the rescheduled date.
The conversation explores the confusion surrounding the decision, especially since the scheduled strikes do not overlap with the original graduation dates. While McKearnen expresses support for the staff's right to industrial action, she highlights the financial burden on students and the lack of clarity regarding the graduation ball and other planned celebrations.
30 Sep 2026
5213-
"There was no stop to the noise"
Listened
This episode explores the growing tensions surrounding public sector industrial action driven by inflation, alongside deep-seated concerns regarding the rapid expansion of data centres in Ireland. Listeners and guests discuss the environmental and social impacts of these developments, including noise pollution, potential PFAS contamination, and the strain on the national electricity grid.
The discussion further examines the economic trade-offs of the data centre industry, weighing corporate tax benefits against the competition for labor needed for essential housing and infrastructure. The episode concludes with calls for better environmental accountability, such as repurposing waste heat and ratifying EU directives to ensure energy efficiency reporting.
30 Sep 2026
5212-
"Most people don't have space to store them"
Listened
This episode explores the growing opposition to Dublin's proposed transition from bin bags to wheelie bins in the inner city. Residents raise significant concerns regarding narrow footpaths, lack of indoor storage, and potential conflicts with disability accessibility laws, while suggesting alternatives like communal shelters or 'gull-proof sacks.'
The discussion also highlights the logistical struggles faced by rural residents, who deal with a lack of regular collection services and the physical burden of transporting waste manually. Amidst these challenges, Councillor Ellen O'Doherty discusses legislative efforts to defer the changes through a council vote to allow for better community engagement.
29 Sep 2026
5211-
"I really need this to be lifted"
Listened
On RTÉ Radio 1's Live Line, host Ciarán Cudahy discusses the prolonged boil water notice affecting Tipperary Town and the Galty scheme. Caller Terry Jackson describes the physical and financial hardships of living under a 33-week notice, including the difficulty of transporting heavy water bottles and the rising costs of electricity for boiling water. Sinn Féin councillor Anne-Marie Ryan joins to provide updates on trial well drilling and highlights broader issues with inconsistent communication from Uisce Éireann and widespread water outages across County Tipperary.
The conversation explores the lack of accountability within the utility's standalone structure, as both callers note that government departments often claim they have no direct function in operational matters. The episode covers the impact on vulnerable populations, the presence of visible leaks in town centers, and the frustration regarding conflicting information provided via text alerts and outage maps.
29 Sep 2026
5210-
"I was left for dead on the side of the road"
Listened
This episode begins with a news roundup covering local issues in Dublin, traffic congestion in Gorey, and long-term boil water notices in Tipperary. The focus then shifts to an emotional interview with Mannix Flynn, who recounts the traumatic details of being struck by a car in Kerry.
Flynn discusses the profound psychological and physical trauma resulting from the hit-and-run accident. He explores the distinction between a genuine accident and the deliberate act of fleeing the scene, expressing the deep sense of vulnerability and the perceived lack of value for human life demonstrated by the driver.
29 Sep 2026
5209-
"We went to support the players"
Listened
Frank recounts his experience traveling to Hungary to support the Irish national team, detailing how fans managed to enter the stadium despite cancelled tickets and reflecting on the intense political pressures faced by players. The episode also explores the debate surrounding the FAI's decision to proceed with the match against Israel, covering criticisms of leadership accountability, player boycotting efforts, and the polarized reactions within the Irish public.
28 Sep 2026
5208-
"It's happening all over again"
Listened
This episode features a debate on Liveline regarding the ongoing standoff at Garvahy Road in Northern Ireland, focusing on the legality of protests and the importance of upholding the rule of law. The discussion covers the complexities of parade routes in Portadown, the responsibilities of political leaders, and potential solutions to avoid future community impasse.
The conversation also explores proposals for compromise to separate the 12th of July march from local resident concerns. Finally, Chris Nelson, the son of assassinated human rights lawyer Rosemary Nelson, shares his traumatic childhood memories of the Troubles and expresses his deep anxiety regarding his wife's involvement in current community standoffs.
28 Sep 2026
5207-
Ireland v Israel
Listened
This episode explores the intense debate surrounding the decision by various publicans to boycott the broadcast of upcoming Nations League football matches involving Israel. Featuring discussions from RTE Radio 1, the program examines the tension between maintaining a neutral sporting environment and taking a political stand regarding the humanitarian situation in Gaza.
Listeners and business owners share diverse perspectives, ranging from those who believe sport should remain separate from politics to those who argue that playing the match ignores the ongoing conflict. The discussion also touches upon the responsibilities of sports organizations, the role of international complicity, and the potential impact of such boycotts on football culture.
25 Sep 2026
5206-
U2 return to Mount Temple
Listened
A reporter interviews Eric, a Mount Temple Comprehensive graduate, as the school prepares to host a U2 concert celebrating the band's 50th anniversary. Eric shares his personal connection to the school, including past encounters with Bono and the profound musical influence U2 has had on students.
Listeners Freya and Eric also recount their experiences attending the anniversary performance. While Freya and her friends were eventually escorted out for lacking wristbands, Eric remained for the full show, witnessing a moving rendition of 'With or Without You'.
25 Sep 2026
5205-
"...an appeal to act with their conscience..."
Listened
This episode of Liveline features a series of heated debates regarding the upcoming fixtures between the Irish men's national football team and Israel. Guests and callers clash over the 'Stop the Game' campaign, discussing whether athletes have a moral obligation to boycott matches based on allegations of genocide and apartheid in Gaza and the West Bank.
The discussion explores the distinction between the Israeli government and its people, the historical parallels between Irish and Palestinian struggles, and the legitimacy of using sports as a platform for political protest. The debate also covers the credibility of international legal proceedings and the complexities of athlete responsibility in politically charged environments.
23 Sep 2026
5204-
"I'm afraid of my life to turn on the heat"
Listened
This episode explores the escalating cost-of-living crisis in Ireland, focusing on the rising prices of fuel, electricity, and kerosene. The discussion highlights the severe financial strain on farmers, who face high carbon taxes without viable green alternatives, and elderly pensioners struggling to afford basic heating.
Participants debate government taxation policies, resource allocation between asylum seekers and healthcare, and the disparity in energy rates between households and data centres. The conversation also touches on potential upcoming fuel protests as a response to economic desperation.
22 Sep 2026
5203-
"Staying at home isn't for everyone"
Listened
This episode of the Lifeline podcast explores the complexities and societal pressures surrounding the choice to be a stay-at-home parent. Through personal accounts from callers Catherine, Brida, and Paula, the discussion addresses the social judgment faced by mothers, the economic necessity forcing parents back into the workforce, and the invisible, undervalued nature of domestic labor.
21 Sep 2026
5202-
"It's creating a handout culture"
Listened
This episode explores the social implications of personal and political choices, beginning with a discussion on the stigma faced by mothers who choose to stay at home to raise children. The conversation then shifts into an extensive debate regarding a proposed €100 government culture voucher for 16-year-olds.
Listeners and guests weigh the potential benefits of increased access to arts and sports against concerns regarding funding priorities, such as homelessness and youth services. The discussion covers the long-term social impact of cultural engagement, the risk of creating a 'handout culture,' and the possibility of political motivations behind the scheme.
21 Sep 2026
5201-
Shelbourne Park's involvement on Culture Night
Listened
A heated debate unfolds regarding the ethics and welfare of greyhound racing in Ireland, sparked by its promotion during Culture Night. The discussion explores conflicting views on animal cruelty, industry mortality statistics, and the use of public funds through the bookmakers' levy.
Participants clash over whether the sport is a vital part of Irish heritage or a 'culture washing' tactic for a gambling-driven industry. The debate further covers the economic impact of racing, recent industry reforms, and the social implications of maintaining traditions that critics argue are no longer morally justifiable.
18 Sep 2026
5200-
Liveline at The Ploughing
Listened
Broadcasting live from the National Ploughing Championships, this episode explores the multifaceted challenges facing the Irish agricultural sector. Through interviews with young farmers and YouTube creators, as well as expert panel discussions, we examine the economic instability caused by uncertainty around CAP funding, nitrates derogation, and rising input costs.
The discussion delves into the difficulty of farm succession for the 'squeezed middle,' the necessity of technological investment to address labor gaps, and the vital role of agricultural supports in ensuring food security and rural community stability. The episode also features musical performances, a tractor trivia quiz, and insights into the future of organic farming and sustainability.
17 Sep 2026
5199-
"Sex is the barometer"
Listened
In this segment, Carmel Wynne discusses the complexities of marital infidelity and the importance of forgiveness in relationships. She explores the connection between communication failures and emotional dissatisfaction, suggesting that many relationship issues stem from partners' inability to communicate needs or recognize emotional cues. The conversation also touches upon generational shifts in how people discuss feelings and intimacy, contrasting the 'muddling through' approach of previous generations with the modern emphasis on emotional awareness.
16 Sep 2026
5198-
"We've €40 in the account"
Listened
An interview regarding the imminent closure of Moatview Education Centre, a community-based childcare charity that has operated for 24 years. The episode details the severe financial crisis facing the centre, including unpaid revenue arrears and an inability to meet payroll for eight staff members due to a lack of available funds.
The discussion explores how administrative discrepancies in TUSLA certification and delays in core funding applications have left the centre with only 40 euro in its account. Despite a recently approved sustainability grant of 22,000 euro from the Dublin City Child Care Committee and Pobal, the amount is insufficient to cover existing arrears or ensure future operational stability.
16 Sep 2026
5197-
Ed Sheeran on Macklemore
Listened
This episode explores the controversy surrounding Ed Sheeran's North American tour, following the removal of support acts like Macklemore due to political statements regarding Palestine. The discussion examines whether Sheeran is being unfairly targeted by personal attacks or if he has failed to demonstrate leadership and solidarity with his fellow artists.
Speakers debate the tension between artistic neutrality and political responsibility, weighing the logistical pressure from promoters against the importance of standing by one's principles. The conversation further explores themes of hypocrisy, comparing Sheeran's previous support for Ukraine to his current silence on Gaza.
16 Sep 2026
5196-
"I was so excited to meet her"
Listened
In this episode of Live Line with Ciarán Cudahy, Leah Call returns to the program to share the profound details of her recent trip to China. After discovering her biological parents through a rapid search process in late summer, Leah traveled to meet them for the first time, accompanied by her adoptive mother.
Leah describes the emotional intensity of reuniting with her birth mother and meeting her biological siblings. She reflects on the surreal experience of seeing her own physical features reflected in her new relatives, the use of AI translation technology to bridge the language gap, and the deep bond she formed with her newfound sister. The conversation explores the complexities of identity, the impact of finding a missing piece of one's history, and the challenges of returning to normal life after such a life-changing encounter.
15 Sep 2026
5195-
"We need to ask what we're trying to solve"
Listened
This episode explores the leaked details of the proposed EU Kids Act, a legislative effort to protect children online through age-based social media restrictions. Guests Aisling Maloney and Leo Galvin critique the proposal, arguing that focusing on age bans shifts responsibility away from tech companies and fails to address harmful platform features like algorithms.
The discussion further examines the debate between implementing age-based bans versus enforcing platform accountability. Panelists argue that primary responsibility should lie with tech companies to ensure 'safety by design' rather than placing the entire burden of online safety on parents.
15 Sep 2026
5194-
"He was extremely, extremely convincing"
Listened
This episode explores the leaked details of the EU Kids Act and its potential impact on social media access for minors. The discussion then shifts to an interview with Rona Cullinan, who recounts a distressing experience with a derelict hotel in Leitrim and a subsequent sophisticated scam.
Rona describes how a fraudster posing as a Booking.com employee used her booking reference to steal €850. She shares the emotional toll of the incident and provides a vital warning to others about protecting their credit card security codes.
15 Sep 2026
5193-
"They put ankle shackles and handcuffs on me"
Listened
Evan Devaney shares his harrowing experience of being detained by ICE in the United States after overstaying his visa, detailing the physical and emotional toll of month-long detention in Tennessee and Louisiana. The episode explores the debate between legal accountability for immigration violations and the fundamental human rights concerns regarding inhumane treatment in detention facilities.
The discussion then transitions to the political landscape of Ireland, examining Donald Trump's comments on Irish unification. Guests weigh the economic risks, such as national debt and social instability, against the historical context of partition and the complexities of integrating a divided Northern Irish population.
14 Sep 2026
5192-
9/11: 25 Years On - Liveline in New York
Listened
Este episódio apresenta relatos emocionantes sobre o 25º aniversário dos ataques de 11 de setembro, trazendo testemunhos de sobreviventes e familiares das vítimas. Através de memórias de pessoas como Catherine Coughlin, Brian Kerrigan e a oficial da NYPD Moira Reddy-Smith, exploramos o impacto humano do colapso das torres, os momentos de desespero durante a evacuação e o legado de perda e resiliência deixado pela tragédia.
A narrativa percorre desde o caos inicial e o impacto no NYPD até histórias de superação pessoal e trauma profundo. O programa também aborda as memórias de quem assistiu aos ataques pela televisão, os áudios históricos de pedidos de socorro e o impacto duradouro do evento na vida daqueles que buscaram reconstruir seus caminhos após o choque.
11 Sep 2026
5191-
Reaction to Michael O'Leary comments
Listened
Este episódio aborda a intensa controvérsia gerada pelas declarações do CEO da Ryanair, Michael O'Leary, que utilizou o termo 'estupro' de forma metafórica para criticar os preços altos de companhias aéreas concorrentes. Através de entrevistas com especialistas como Rachel Morrow, do Dublin Rape Crisis Centre, e relatos emocionantes de ouvintes, o debate explora como o uso casual dessa linguagem pode trivializar a violência sexual, reforçar a normalização da violência e impactar profundamente os sobreviventes.
A discussão também reflete sobre a responsabilidade de figuras públicas na manutenção de um discurso respeitoso, o impacto do conteúdo mediático na percepção de jovens sobre crimes sexuais e as dificuldades enfrentadas por famílias e vítimas ao lidar com o sistema judicial e o trauma pessoal.
10 Sep 2026
5190-
The GAA gubu
Listened
This episode features a series of heated debates on the Live Line regarding the potential amalgamation of the GAA, LGFA, and Camogie associations. Listeners and guests weigh the complexities of integrating men's and women's Gaelic games, focusing on disparities in resource allocation, funding, and facility access at the grassroots level.
The discussion covers a wide range of perspectives, from criticisms of systemic sexism and unequal developmental paths for children to arguments for maintaining separate organizations to ensure autonomy. Callers also address the logistical burdens of managing multiple committees and the financial challenges facing women's sporting branches.
09 Sep 2026
5189-
"I was expecting to hear hopefully she had got out. I didn't hear that news."
Listened
O episódio apresenta um relato emocionante de Patrick McHugh sobre o impacto dos ataques de 11 de setembro de 2001, focando na perda de sua irmã, Anne-Marie, que trabalhava na Torre Sul do World Trade Center. O programa detalha a experiência de Patrick ao receber a notícia e sua viagem a Nova York para tentar encontrá-la.
A narrativa explora como o evento transformou a vida da família McHugh, desde a busca por respostas até a eventual aceitação da perda. Além disso, discute como o trauma do atentado influenciou a carreira de Patrick na TSA (Transportation Security Administration) e como ele planeja honrar a memória de sua irmã.
08 Sep 2026
5188-
"Why should the Irish taxpayer pay for it? It is not an official visit."
Listened
This episode features a heated debate regarding the approximately £20 million security expenditure for Donald Trump's upcoming visit to Ireland for the Irish Open. Callers and hosts weigh the burden on taxpayers during a cost-of-living crisis against the risks of diplomatic and economic fallout.
Perspectives range from criticizing the expenditure as pandering to arguing for the importance of diplomatic protocol and respect. The discussion also touches upon domestic issues like homelessness and questions the timing of the visit relative to the 9/11 anniversary.
08 Sep 2026
5187-
Sheep welfare in Traitors
Listened
O episódio aborda uma controvérsia envolvendo o bem-estar animal durante a gravação de um desafio no programa 'The Traitors'. Os interlocutores debatem as condições das ovelhas utilizadas na produção, com acusações de estresse, isolamento de animais e sinais de má nutrição ou falta de cuidados sanitários.
A discussão confronta os relatos de maus-tratos e negligência com a nota oficial da Kite Entertainment, que defende que todos os protocolos de bem-estar foram seguidos e que o uso dos animais ocorreu em uma fazenda em funcionamento sob supervisão profissional.
08 Sep 2026
5186-
"To me it's gaslighting women..."
Listened
O episódio aborda a preocupação crescente de mulheres na Irlanda sobre a falta de transparência nos resultados do Breast Check em relação à densidade do tecido mamário. O debate foca no impacto clínico para 43% das mulheres que possuem tecido denso, o que pode dificultar a detecção precoce de certos tipos de câncer.
A discussão explora os processos de revisão governamental e as previsões de mudanças nas diretrizes apenas para 2028, levantando questões sobre equidade no cuidado à saúde, autonomia da paciente e o risco de diagnósticos tardios. Participantes como a Senadora Nessa Cosgrove questionam a demora nos processos de avaliação e defendem a necessidade de acesso imediato a essas informações.
07 Sep 2026
5185-
"When do you stop being a foreigner?"
Listened
Este episódio aborda as novas e rigorosas regras para a obtenção de cidadania na Irlanda, que incluem o aumento do tempo de residência para oito anos e a exigência de testes de proficiência linguística. O debate explora as tensões entre segurança nacional, controle de fronteiras e os impactos socioeconômicos da migração.
A discussão também mergulha na crise habitacional irlandesa, questionando se o problema reside na imigração ou em políticas de fundos corporativos. Os participantes debatem temas profundos como o aumento do racismo, a importância dos imigrantes para o sistema de saúde e os desafios de identidade enfrentados por aqueles que, apesar da integração, ainda lutam para serem plenamente aceitos como irlandeses.